| Premier League | 1 | 1893-09-02 | HOME | Blackburn Rovers | 2-3 |
| Premier League | 2 | 1893-09-04 | AWAY | Burnley | 5-1 |
| Premier League | 3 | 1893-09-09 | AWAY | Sheffield United | 2-1 |
| Premier League | 4 | 1893-09-16 | HOME | Stoke City | 3-1 |
| Premier League | 5 | 1893-09-18 | AWAY | Wolverhampton Wanderers | 2-1 |
| Premier League | 6 | 1893-09-23 | AWAY | Preston North End | 4-1 |
| Premier League | 7 | 1893-09-30 | HOME | Manchester United | 1-0 |
| Premier League | 7 | 1893-10-07 | AWAY | Bolton Wanderers | 1-0 |
| Premier League | 9 | 1893-10-14 | HOME | Aston Villa | 1-1 |
| Premier League | 10 | 1893-10-21 | AWAY | Everton | 8-1 |
| Premier League | 10 | 1893-10-28 | HOME | Bolton Wanderers | 1-3 |
| Premier League | 12 | 1893-11-04 | AWAY | Manchester United | 0-1 |
| Premier League | 13 | 1893-11-11 | HOME | West Bromwich Albion | 2-1 |
| Premier League | 14 | 1893-11-18 | AWAY | Derby County | 2-1 |
| Premier League | 15 | 1893-12-02 | AWAY | Stoke City | 3-1 |
| Premier League | 16 | 1893-12-11 | HOME | Sheffield Wednesday | 2-1 |
| Premier League | 17 | 1893-12-16 | AWAY | West Bromwich Albion | 2-2 |
| Premier League | 18 | 1893-12-23 | HOME | Nottingham Forest | 0-4 |
| Premier League | 19 | 1893-12-25 | AWAY | Blackburn Rovers | 4-1 |
| Premier League | 22 | 1893-12-26 | AWAY | Aston Villa | 9-0 |
| Premier League | 21 | 1894-01-01 | HOME | Everton | 3-3 |
| Premier League | 22 | 1894-01-06 | HOME | Sheffield United | 3-3 |
| Premier League | 23 | 1894-01-15 | AWAY | Sheffield Wednesday | 5-0 |
| Premier League | 24 | 1894-02-03 | HOME | Preston North End | 2-1 |
| Premier League | 25 | 1894-02-06 | HOME | Burnley | 0-0 |
| Premier League | 26 | 1894-03-10 | HOME | Wolverhampton Wanderers | 3-1 |
| Premier League | 27 | 1894-03-15 | AWAY | Nottingham Forest | 4-1 |
| Premier League | 28 | 1894-03-27 | AWAY | Sunderland | 4-0 |
| Premier League | 29 | 1894-04-07 | HOME | Sunderland | 0-3 |
| Premier League | 30 | 1894-04-14 | HOME | Derby County | 2-3 |
